Whether it's the climate crisis, species extinction or the energy transition - planting trees is often seen as a kind of ‘magic bullet’ that will solve almost all of our problems. However, the issue is much more complex than it first appears.

Tree planting is not a panacea

Tree planting campaign in the Uckermark © Sonja Ritter / WWF
Tree planting campaign in the Uckermark © Sonja Ritter / WWF

We need to do something, because our forests are in worse shape than ever before. The Federal Forest Report 2021 clearly shows the devastating effects of the droughts of previous years: 277,000 hectares of German forest, the vast majority of which are non-native coniferous forests, have been severely damaged or have died completely. This corresponds to an area larger than the Saarland or about three times the size of Berlin. It is precisely through the mass planting of conifer monocultures that we are largely responsible for this new forest dieback. These monocultures also provide a habitat for only a few species and thus contribute to species extinction. Planting such forests again would be disastrous and irresponsible.

Mixed deciduous forests, on the other hand, which would occur naturally in most locations, are better equipped to withstand extreme weather events. For this reason, when planting trees, it should always be scrutinized which tree species should be planted. Extreme caution is required with trees that are not native to the site.

 

So why don't we just plant deciduous trees?

This is already being done in many forestry operations. However, the large-scale planting of new forests is already failing due to the fact that we do not have enough land in Germany for reforestation. This also means that no new CO2 certificates can be issued for these areas, as this would mean a double calculation. They are therefore not suitable for CO2 offsetting by companies.

Planting spade ready for planting © Sonja Ritter / WWF
Planting spade ready for planting © Sonja Ritter / WWF

This makes it all the more important that we make our existing forest areas fit for the future. And replanting oaks and beeches in places where there are no hardwood parent trees can certainly make sense. For example, in large-scale conifer monocultures. 

With the help of planting helpers such as jays and the like, coupled with effective wildlife management, nature plants the forest all by itself. This not only creates a structurally rich, natural forest, but also saves us a lot of work. In addition, forests planted by nature are more resilient, as the root system has been able to develop on the site from the outset. And so they can also save more CO2 for longer. When it comes to protecting natural processes, we need to move away from the idea of highly productive timber fields. In future, quality will take precedence over quantity.

However, we not only need commercial forests, but also forests where the sawmill is at rest and the trees are allowed to grow and age. This is because the aging and decay phases of forests are particularly rare in our commercial forests. The Bavarian Forest and Harz National Parks set a good example here, as the forest is allowed to regenerate undisturbed by humans over large areas. But the WWF also shows how ‘primeval forests of tomorrow’ are created over the course of years, decades and centuries.

It is true that all trees bind a lot of carbon dioxide (CO2) and convert it into biomass and oxygen. They are important for the regional climate by evaporating water and thus cooling in summer and protecting the forest floor from drying out, they increase water retention in the landscape and enrich humus in the soil - which also binds a lot of CO2.

They are also a habitat, food source and recreational area for animals, plants and humans. The ecosystem services provided by trees are therefore diverse and essential for a living planet. With all these positive characteristics of trees, the question of whether tree planting makes sense should be self-explanatory, right?

Oak seedlings at a tree planting campaign in the Uckermark © Sonja Ritter / WWF
Oak seedlings at a tree planting campaign in the Uckermark © Sonja Ritter / WWF

WWF helps nature to help itself

On more than 4,500 hectares of owned land, including around 3,500 hectares of forest, we simply want to let nature be nature. Because if you leave the forests to their own devices and only help them with minimal intervention, amazing things happen. Beech, oak, maple, lime and many other tree species grow all by themselves.

On our areas in the Barsdorf Forest and the Zerweliner Heide in Brandenburg, we are creating the primeval forests of tomorrow. We keep interventions to a minimum here, planting is only carried out in small areas in exceptional cases. This is the only way our forest still has a future, even in the light of the climate crisis.

So können Sie helfen